Posts Tagged ‘cbi’

Narendra Modi , CBI & Congress Saga

Saturday, July 31st, 2010

Narendra Modi with Anil Ambani during VGGIS 2003
Image via Wikipedia

Narendra Damodar Modi , the chief minister of gujarat since 2002 , the figure who is one of most controversial in Indian politics . The name which is equally hated and equally loved. Hated by many who believe him to have facilitated gujarat riots by not acting on time. Loved by industrialist and people of right wing as well as majority of gujaratis.

Known as sharp , intelligent , no nonsense and fast in development plans , narendra modi is longest serving chief minister of gujarat. He has been single handily credited to have taken on grand old party of India and made it to be almost non existing entity in gujarat.

The ghost of riots still haunts him. Gujarat riots of 2002 were third  riots in subcontinent accused to be facilitated by state (directly or indirectly ) and first one in era of 24 by 7 channel. Anti sikh riots of 1982 was equally worse riot while muslim league sponsered riots of 1946 in calcutta was among first such riots.

Gujarat riots was well published all across the globe . Modi was criticized from all corners and even then prime minister of India (atal bihari vajpayee) advised modi to follow raj dharm.

The election held soon after riots was highly polarized ones , with both insecure communities voting on basis of who would be able to protect them. Modi won and that set , what can be said as modi era. Modi tried hard to get rid of his communal image. He distanced himself from vhp , bajrang dal , he undertook major development steps , he started events like vibrant gujarat calling all whose’s who from industrial world , he even didnt hesitate to get temples removed from streets to facilitate broading the road.

When next election came , gujarat riots was past and narendra modi pitched on development for votes. Narendra modi fought three different entities to win the election.  Rival congress , media and most importantly his own party people who were working against him. He single handily demolished all three and brought BJP back in power.

While he remained powerful force in gujarat , outside gujarat his presence proved disaster for BJP and its allies. The development man in gujarat is seen as facist outside gujarat.

Congress is last election tried to use riot to nail modi. It back fired. Why it back fired needs another blog post to answer but reason why gujarat shuns congress is congress itself . BJP is consequence of congress’s policy . It is after effect and not the effect.

Coming back to congress’s strategy in last election. The more it attacked modi , the more beneficial it became for modi. He is smart politicians who knows how to use opponent’s comments to his advantage which he did during last state elections.

Now as CBI is investigating case of sohrabuddin and has already arrested amit shah , narendra modi is going all out to hit back at congress while congress having learnt from experience of last election is refusing to mention modi’s name in any of interviews.

BJP and narendra modi are accusing congress of using CBI as tool to counter modi in gujarat. Narendra modi also took dig on congress by stating that in next elections , congress would field cbi personnel as their candidate. Today again narendra modi attacked center government and he is expected to link gujarat’s self respect with this case.

CBI on other hand is tighting the noose. It has asked supreme court to move case away from gujarat and also has sought more time from the court. It has requested court to give three months time period since it believes the case would go beyond amit shah (indirectly it means it might have narendra modi too in the case).

As cbi is tightening the noose , SIT has already questioned modi in riot case. Both CBI and SIT report directly to supreme court and supreme court is highest authority as far as law goes.

Sure , coming days are tough for narendra modi and if he survives SIT (CBI has not named him in sohrabuddin case) , it would be difficult for congress to get back in gujarat. If supreme court finds narendra modi to be not guilty , it would be Modi rule in gujarat for long long time.

Congress , on other hand is refraining from attacking narendra modi and distancing itself from sohrabuddin case ,amidst allegation that though inquiry has been directed by supreme court , congress is directing CBI.

Would SIT nail modi , would cbi try to book modi in sohrabuddin case?, is congress directing cbi?, is congress hoping law gets modi , would modi turn victorious ?. Time would only answer this question. As of now it is modi v/s congress saga with episode called sohrabuddin fake encounter and cbi.

Enhanced by Zemanta

Sohrabuddin & Amit Shah Saga : What is silver lining?

Sunday, July 25th, 2010

Amit shah is in news all across India. Modi’s man , ex home minister of gujarat who went missing , resigned and then re emerged has been sent to 14 day judicial custody. The big political news in which both congress and bjp made allegations and counter allegations using media as medium.

When majority of Indians were having holiday , Indian news media was having one of busiest days of the year. The re emerging amit shah had press conference before he went to cbi office. CBI which refused to give time to amit shah , surprisingly didnt take shah in their custody !!!!!!!!!!

As amit shah called this political encounter , congress slammed BJP stating that it is too later to cry foul since CBI was in scene since six months. BJP reacted that why amit shah was not arrested earlier if CBI has prove and questioned the timing. While BJP states that CBI is being misused , prime minister of India dismissed the charges outrightly.

BJP’s defense that sohrabuddin was terrorist with more weapons than kasab doesnot hold much grounds. Case is not about who sohrabuddin was. Even if one concedes that sohrabuddin was terrorist who was arms supplier , does it give right to police to over rule constitution , kidnap him and kill him. Is this how we want our country to function?. Do we want to become banana republic and operate like taliban or khaps do?

Sohrabuddin should have been arrested and case should have been conducted against it. I perfectly understand general feeling about our legal system. Cases go on and on and on. Witness turn hostile and quite often terrorist wait for their turn in mercy petition. Government plays various cards to safeguard their votes and in the end ‘aam aadmi’ feels vunerable , outraged and helpless.

Having said that we need to work on improving the system , rather then taking leaf out of taliban or unstable countries in how they would have reacted in such cases.

Coming to Amit Shah , he has every right to defend himself . The case would be argued in court and court would decide. It is neither for media or people or congress or bjp to decide whether amit shah is guilty or innocent.

As this much debated issue proceeds towards conclusion (one way or the other) , there is surely a silver lining in the case. Sohrabuddin is said to be notorious criminal who was also arms supplier. What ever he was , at least he was Indian citizen . When his brother wrote to supreme court , it accepted the letter as petition and directed CID of gujarat to look into the matter. CID booked 11 police officers , many IPS out of them and arrested them. Later case came to CBI.

The silver lining in the entire saga is supreme court . It gives faith to aam aadmi that who ever you are , what ever you are , supreme court is there. In highly corrupted system where politicians are same in every party , where faith on police force is less , judiciary still works to get matter investigated.

Amidst all allegations and counter allegations , amidst media buzzing with various news about saga , amidst congress using/misusing cbi , amidst BJP projecting itself as victim , amidst all news about sohrabuddin , one message stands tall. One message which gives hope , one message which proves that constitution works and that message for all aam aadmi is from supreme court , that it is there.